
Arthur Hayes
Key Views & Dialogues
Arthur Hayes On The Early Days Of BitMEX, Where Bitcoin Is Going, And Why We Are Over-Indexing On AI
BitMEX found product-market fit in a crowded spot-exchange market by pairing high leverage with perpetual swaps as Bitcoin rose. Hayes says it exited without losing customer funds, but the insurance fund’s disposition remains unresolved. He sees government support for AI firms as a possible crypto catalyst, while Flop Network remains a speculative bet on cheap compute and agent growth.
View summary (7)
BitMEX emerged from Hayes’s experience of institutional fragility and an underserved derivatives market. His first trading-desk day coincided with Lehman’s bankruptcy; after Citi let him go in 2013, he found Bitcoin, traded arbitrage and founded BitMEX in 2014. Spot exchanges were already crowded, while derivatives remained primitive enough that traders could double their money on a three-month cash-and-carry trade—provided the exchange survived.
BitMEX found product-market fit by offering 100X leverage, then invented the perpetual swap to simplify a product customers did not understand. The initial conservative futures contract lost to Chinese venues offering 20X; better technology let BitMEX jump to 100X and become cash-flow positive as Bitcoin rose from roughly $130 to $600 in late 2015. After the first perp design failed, the May 2016 version concentrated liquidity and used a self-referencing funding mechanism designed to “punish people who are going with the trend” and attract market makers against it.
Hayes views BitMEX’s closure as both sad and liberating because custody was “a terrible way to live.” The exchange reached roughly 250 employees and, he said, exited without ever losing customer funds. Its product remained widely used as crypto, in his framing, took over TradFi. He declined to explain the disposition of an insurance fund with “30-something thousand Bitcoin” left in it, calling the matter “TBD.”
Hayes remains overwhelmingly positioned for crypto’s long-term monetary thesis rather than short-horizon trading. “Ninety-something percent” of his net worth is in crypto, although he keeps enough real estate, gold, stocks and T-bills to be fine if it goes to zero; Maelstrom’s speculative directional positions generally run one to six months. Trading remains an intellectual game whose objective scorecard is money made or lost.
Hayes is bearish on AI stocks but believes AI will be useful; his objection is that customers are not paying the technology’s full economic cost. He argued that perhaps 95% of users would leave if pricing covered training, inference and profit, citing Anthropic’s stated 2025 ratio of $3 of cost for every $1 of revenue. Meanwhile, data-center inputs become scarcer and more expensive as the commodity they produce—compute—gets cheaper, creating an “upside down chart.”
His base case is that the AI build-out becomes too systemically important to fail, forcing monetary support that ultimately benefits crypto, including his long-Bitcoin thesis. Hayes assigned a 75% probability that Anthropic, SpaceX, OpenAI and similar companies will not be able to afford their five-year compute commitments without government assistance because demand will not reach profitable pricing at sufficient scale. Avi challenged the benign political reading, warning that an AI bailout could provoke a sharp leftward swing; Hayes answered that leaders of every ideology eventually choose another bailout over personally crashing the economy.
The apparent contradiction in Hayes’s AI view powers his new bet: failed AI economics could make agents abundant while creating demand for a compute-linked currency. Flop Network would reward GPU operators for useful inference and let agents convert Flop directly into their “life force,” compute. If trillions or quadrillions of agents each retain a small convenience balance, Hayes believes the network could become “the largest cryptocurrency ever, bigger than Bitcoin”—an explicitly speculative claim resting on cheap surplus compute and explosive agent growth.
Arthur Hayes: BTC Price Targets, Trading Advice, Bear Market and More | TG Podcast
Hayes frames Bitcoin below $100,000 as a leverage-and-time-horizon problem, with his 12-to-18-month bull case resting on continued easing. His Zcash thesis links possible 10%-20% of Bitcoin’s value to AI-driven surveillance and privacy infrastructure, while acknowledging the vehicle may differ. His HYPE framework prioritizes token value accrual and Bitcoin accumulation; HIP-3 execution, low-fee competition, and political austerity remain key variables.
View summary (8)
Hayes treats Bitcoin below $100,000 as a leverage-and-time-horizon problem, not a broken thesis. Maelstrom is roughly 98% invested, keeps little cash, and uses no leverage, allowing him to sit through volatility while traders paying perpetual funding must get both direction and timing right. His blunt reminder: “The market doesn’t give a shit about your time scale.”
His 12-to-18-month bull case rests on the absence of a credit contraction, with political austerity as the clear invalidation. Unlike late 2021, when central banks were preparing to raise rates, Hayes now sees widespread easing, possible renewed Fed QE, an end to QT, and eventual Fed and PBOC money printing. Republicans and Democrats market spending differently, but both promise benefits without commensurate taxes—meaning the bill arrives through “the inflation tax.”
Bitcoin and gold are complementary debasement trades because their marginal buyers are different. Hayes describes Bitcoin as “the people’s answer” and gold as the institutionally safe choice for sovereigns unwilling to risk careers on a 15-year-old asset when gold has served that function for thousands of years. His non-crypto portfolio is essentially physical gold, gold miners, and silver miners: “It’s not one or the other.”
Zcash became Hayes’s main current altcoin focus after Naval pitched it as his next-biggest bag and a possible remaining 1,000x opportunity. Hayes first bought before completing diligence—“invest first, investigate later”—then said his follow-up research supported claims about Halo 2, Japanese Monero deanonymization, and the phaseout of Zcash’s mining subsidy. He believes Zcash could reach 10%-20% of Bitcoin’s value and likes that it produces both intense love and hate: “I want pathos. I want emotion.”
The larger Zcash thesis is that AI-driven surveillance will make privacy a five-to-ten-year infrastructure theme. Hayes expects governments to pair increasingly capable predictive systems with the immense personal datasets users voluntarily surrendered, making private transactions, ZK identity, ZKYC, and proof of humanity more valuable. He hedges the vehicle—“maybe that’s Zcash, maybe that’s something else”—but not the direction of travel.
Selling HYPE did not necessarily negate Hayes’s still-possible 126x long-term thesis because Maelstrom’s operating objective is to accumulate more Bitcoin. His model is to buy an asset at X, sell around 3X, stack sats, and potentially re-enter at X or below while watching whether Hyperliquid can out-execute low-fee competitors and expand through HIP-3. “You have to be able to hold two contradictory ideas in your mind at the same time.”
Token value accrual has finally become non-negotiable after repeated cycles of governance tokens that paid holders nothing. Hayes contrasts UNI’s fall from roughly $35-$40 to $3-$4 and DYDX’s former $28-$30 billion FDV with Hyperliquid’s no-VC model and direct alignment with token holders. His rule for founders is categorical: “You better hand the money back or be a zero. Choose one.”
For newcomers, Hayes rejects the pressure to hyper-gamble unless they are prepared to become full-time market-structure specialists. A leverage trader must monitor funding, open interest, stops, and Asia, Europe, and North America flows “24/7, 365”; everyone else should allocate a fixed share of savings to high-quality crypto, avoid leverage, and let compounding work. Even 5% compounded patiently can create wealth without the ruinous drawdowns of swinging for an immediate escape.